Fresno State political science professor Dr. Michael Becker and Director
of the Islamic Cultural Center of Fresno, Kamal Abu-Shamasieh were part
of the 9/11, Ten Years Later discussion panel.
Alicia Acevedo / The Collegian
Over 250 attendees and panel members participated in the 9/11 Ten Years Later discussion panel, hosted by the Ethics Center on Monday.
Panelists discussed the historical, ethical and practical implications of 9/11 while reflecting on the 10th anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks.
“I want the people to think objectively. This is the opportune time to reflect on what has happened,” Fresno State student, who helped organize the event, Randy Walter said.
While the United States underwent many changes, the panelists agreed that the biggest change was the effect of the United States Patriot Act of 2001. The law overarching goal was to “intercept and obstruct” terrorism.
A recurring theme on the panel was McCarthyism and the spirit of fear that has persisted since 9/11.
McCarthyism is the act of accusing an individual of something that is untrue orunacceptable by society.
McCarthyism is named after Joseph McCarthy, who in the 1950s accused many Americans of Communism.
Several Middle Eastern Fresno State students spoke of their experiences in airport security checkpoints and how they have been subject to more airport checks than other passangers.
“Muslim are not the targets,” former supervisory Special Agent of the FBI Thomas Knowles said. “Radicals and extremist such as al-Qaida and the Taliban do not represent the entire 1.9 million Muslims in the world.”
“There are extreme radicals in every kind of society and everyone has them, so to say that Islam as a religion is the driving force of terrorism is ridiculous,” Knowles added. “The people need to look up their facts.”
Director of the Islamic Cultural Center of Fresno, Kamal Abu-Shamsieh feels that there is an escalated negative impression that America has on the Islamic religion.
“The extremists that committed the attacks are less than one percent of the Muslim population,” Abu-Shamsieh added.
An unidentified student of the audience said, “They hate our freedom here because we don’t let them have it there.”
Walter encourages students to “separate themselves from [the 9/11 attack] and look at it scholastically.”
The panelists included the former supervisory Special Agent of the FBI, the director of the Islamic Cultural Center of Fresno and Bill McEwen from the Fresno Bee.
Several history, philosophy and political science professors also participated in the discussion panel.
Sponsors of the event included Phi Alpha Theta from the History Honor Society, the Ethics Center, the philosophy club, Phi Kappa Phi, history department and the Fresno Historical Society.
The 9/11 discussion panel was one of several events planned by the Ethics Center, among them the Oct. 3 event, Media Responsibility, Ethics, and Civility and the October 13 to 15 event Ethics, Religion, and Civil Discourse.
The event “was a good example of civil discourse,” Dr. Andrew Fiala from the department of philosophy said. Fiala added that there were disagreements but everyone treated each other with respect.
Sarah Crawford • Sep 16, 2011 at 11:38 am
I have come to expect that articles from the Collegian will always be rife with spelling errors, however, Professor Andrew Fiala deserves better than to have his name misspelled by his own university’s rag. Fire your fact checker and proof reader.
Philosotroll • Sep 16, 2011 at 4:21 pm
I appears that they corrected that one spelling error (without noting that they made a correction; generally considered a bad policy in journalism) but still haven’t corrected the misspelling of Randy Wolter’s name and the misspelling of McCarthyism (which is mispelled twice)…
Hopefully the next issue (or even an update to the web article) will feature a note that there were some spelling and grammar errors, as well as factual errors and misquotations.
Philosotroll • Sep 16, 2011 at 8:09 pm
And now they’ve corrected “McCarthyism”, but not Randy’s name and the ‘million’/’billion’ error that they are attributing to Mr. Knowles.
I’m just assuming there will be something printed about this on Monday.
Philosotroll • Sep 16, 2011 at 8:18 am
It was a great event, and I’m glad the Collegian is reporting events on campus. A few notes, though:
Randy’s last name is mispelled. It’s Wolter, not Walter; at least the last time I checked his facebook page.
Knowles is misquoted. It should be “1.9 billion [with a “B”] Muslims around the world.” I think he’s a little bit over on that number; but 1.9 million would be off by an order of magnitude. The number I’m familiar with is between 1.3-1.6 billion.
Also, technically, McEwan wasn’t a panelist; he was moderating the panel.
Still, thanks for the writeup. It was a terrific event, and we hope that the Collegian comes out to support more student run events like this one, thoughout the semester.